Atmospheric Data Settles Delhi’s Stubble Burning Debate

Every year, the debate resumes: Is stubble burning responsible for the poisonous air that engulfs Delhi-NCR from late October, or is the city simply choking on pollution from its own vehicles and industry? It is time to settle this debate once and for all.

To understand what is polluting Delhi, I have analysed meteorological data from IMD stations, air pollution data from all 59 continuous monitoring stations, and stubble-burning data from both polar-orbiting and geostationary satellites. The analysis covers 26 October to 5 November 2026, a period that divides neatly into three distinct phases: before rains (26–28 Oct), influenced by rains (29–31 Oct), and post-rain (1–5 Nov).

Delhi’s pollution began rising on 26 October, when the PM2.5 concentration was 72 µg/m³. By 5 November, it had reached 226 µg/m³—a threefold increase in just 10 days.  There was one break: during 29-31 October, rain and winds cleaned the air, bringing PM2.5 down to 32 µg/m³ on 30 October.

The usual explanation for this rapid rise in pollution is the weather. In winter, air near the ground becomes colder than the air a few hundred metres above it. This creates a temperature inversion, where warm air sits over cold air like a lid on a pot, trapping pollution close to the ground. Add calm winds, and the pot gets no stirring either. Scientists combine the height of this lid (mixing height) and wind speed to calculate Ventilation Coefficient (VC). It tells us how effectively the atmosphere can disperse pollution.

So, did Delhi’s VC start declining from 26 October, when pollution began rising? No. It remained between 300-800 m²/s throughout the period. A VC below 2,000 m²/s indicates poor conditions for dispersing pollution. Delhi was well below this threshold. Temperature inversion and calm winds, therefore, cannot account for the threefold rise in PM2.5.

Could Delhi’s own emissions have tripled instead? There is no evidence of that either. In fact, from 1 November, non-BS-VI vehicles registered outside Delhi were barred from entering the city, which should have reduced traffic emissions. Yet nitrogen oxides (NOx), pollutants closely associated with vehicle exhaust, showed no major change.

Between 26 October and 5 November, NOx rose marginally, from 41 to 53 ppb, while PM2.5 tripled. The ratio of PM2.5 to NOx, therefore, more than doubled, from 1.7 to 4.3. In simple terms, fine particle pollution increased far more sharply than pollution associated with vehicle exhaust. This suggests that vehicles were not the main reason for the sudden rise in PM2.5.

Could industries have caused the surge? The data suggest otherwise. Sulphur dioxide, associated with burning fuels in industries and other sources, remained almost unchanged at 11–13 µg/m³ throughout the period.

What about dust from roads and construction? This, too, cannot explain the surge. The ratio of PM10 to PM2.5 actually declined, meaning that larger particles, typically associated with dust, made up a smaller share of the total particulate pollution. The evidence, therefore, points to a clear conclusion: Delhi’s own sources cannot lead to threefold increase in PM2.5.

Then what explains the surge? Two things changed around 31 October. First, Delhi’s winds shifted from northeasterly to west and west-southwesterly, bringing air from Punjab, Haryana and Rajasthan. Second, stubble burning increased sharply in these states.

The number of farm fires detected by satellites increased more than fivefold, from 178 on 26 October to 1,010 on 3 November. But even these numbers greatly underestimate the actual burning. Many farmers in Punjab and Haryana deliberately light fires after 3 pm, avoiding detection by satellites that pass overhead around 1:30 pm. Smoke from thousands of these fires rides the high-altitude winds, spreading across the entire Indo-Gangetic Plain.

Nothing other than stubble burning, therefore, can explain threefold increase in PM2.5. Without the incoming smoke, I estimate that Delhi’s average PM2.5 levels during 1–5 November would have been around 90–110 µg/m³, rather than the recorded levels of 141-226 µg/m³. So, roughly half of Delhi’s PM2.5 pollution came be attributed to stubble burning.

We can continue arguing about vehicles and industries, and pollution from these sources must certainly be reduced throughout the year. But if we want to substantially improve Delhi’s air quality from late October to early December, eliminating stubble burning must be a priority.

The anatomy of pollution

 

 

Mumbai’s pollution can be halved in five years, but target must be MMR, not just the city

Ask any Mumbaikar, and they will describe the haze that now regularly covers the city’s skyline. A grey blanket that was uncommon two decades ago has become a familiar sight. This is not merely a perception; ground-based monitoring stations and satellite data confirm the deterioration.

Until 2006, Mumbai’s annual average PM10 concentration remained around 60–80 µg/m³, relatively low by Indian standards. However, pollution levels began rising after 2006 and reached 166 µg/m³ in 2018. Although official figures indicate a decline since then, Mumbai’s PM10 concentration was still 88 µg/m³ in 2025, approximately 1.5 times the national standard.

Annual averages, however, do not reveal the full extent of the problem. Mumbai experiences seasonal variations in air pollution. Air quality is comparatively better between June and September because monsoon rains clear the atmosphere, while pollution becomes high to severe between October and March.

During peak pollution months, PM10 concentrations can reach three to four times the national standard. The national standard itself is relatively lenient. During winter, Mumbai’s air pollution can be 10–15 times higher than the level considered safe by the World Health Organization (WHO).

Why has a city that once took pride in its clean air and mocked Delhi for its smog deteriorated so rapidly?

An airshed, not a city

Mumbai’s air pollution is influenced by its wider airshed, which includes at least the Mumbai Metropolitan Region (MMR) and surrounding industrial areas.

The region is geographically surrounded by the Arabian Sea in the west and the Western Ghats in the east. During winter, cold and humid conditions, combined with the Western Ghats acting as a partial barrier, restrict the movement of polluted air and trap pollution within this basin.

This airshed covers approximately 7,000 sq km, while the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) governs only 6% of this area.

Over the last two decades, Mumbai has expanded, but the growth across the rest of MMR has been even more significant.

Population: Since 2011, MMR has gained at least 3.9 million residents, of whom 3.2 million settled outside BMC limits. While Mumbai had a larger population within its municipal boundaries in 2011, this situation had reversed by 2025.

Built-up area: Since 2017, BMC has added approximately 10.5 sq km of roads, bridges, buildings and other developed infrastructure. In comparison, the remaining MMR has added around 270 sq km. Over eight years, development outside Mumbai covered an area comparable to Nashik Municipality.

Vehicles: The number of registered vehicles in MMR has almost tripled since 2011, increasing from 4.36 million to 12.31 million. Six out of every ten vehicles are now registered outside BMC limits.

Industry: Of approximately 33,700 industrial units monitored by the Maharashtra Pollution Control Board (MPCB) across MMR, only 25% are located within Mumbai. The remaining 75% operate outside the city.

In other words, substantial urbanisation, motorisation and industrialisation have taken place largely beyond BMC’s jurisdiction. This is a major contributor to the rise in pollution.

Yet, every winter, the focus of pollution-control action remains primarily on BMC. Mumbai’s air cannot be cleaned without addressing pollution across the entire MMR.

What pollutes Mumbai

There is currently no comprehensive pollution inventory for MMR.

However, BMC’s latest pollution inventory, which can broadly be applied to MMR, identifies the following major contributors to PM10 pollution:

  • Road and construction dust: 26%
  • Industries: 23%
  • Transportation: 20%
  • Waste burning: 14%
  • Cooking fuels used in homes and eateries: 14%

Together, these sources contribute approximately 96% of the PM10 pollution load.

What MMR must do

Think regional

MMR requires a comprehensive regional clean-air plan and a dedicated regional air-quality authority to coordinate efforts among municipalities, government agencies and other authorities.

Unlike Delhi, where regional pollution-control decisions require coordination among five states, the entire MMR region falls within Maharashtra. This makes coordinated action more achievable.

Develop implementable plans

The existing clean-air plans of Mumbai, Navi Mumbai, Thane, Vasai-Virar, Ulhasnagar and Badlapur have several shortcomings.

Their proposed actions and responsibilities are often unclear, measurable targets are missing, and implementation timelines are frequently unrealistic.

A regional clean-air plan must establish clearly defined responsibilities, measurable targets, dedicated budgets and practical deadlines.

Don’t copy Delhi

Mumbai should avoid simply adopting Delhi’s most visible pollution-control measures, including the odd-even vehicle scheme, cloud seeding and restrictions under the Graded Response Action Plan (GRAP).

Such reactive interventions can adversely affect poorer communities and the environment without delivering lasting improvements in air quality.

Put teeth into enforcement

MMR has approximately 19,000 polluting industrial units, responsible for nearly one-third of the region’s pollution.

Two major changes are necessary: industries must transition towards cleaner fuels such as gas and electricity, and online pollution monitoring must become more effective.

For instance, hundreds of small industrial boilers across the region consume approximately two million tonnes of coal annually. Their emissions can only be reduced by switching to cleaner energy sources and establishing shared boiler facilities.

Enforcement also needs to become stronger. Although many industries have installed Continuous Emissions Monitoring Systems (CEMS), these systems are often poorly operated.

MPCB must independently verify the quality of CEMS data, use the information for regulatory compliance and take strict action against industries that violate pollution standards.

Build without dust storms

More than 10,000 construction sites operate across MMR. Controlling construction dust simply by sending inspectors to individual sites is not sufficient.

Dust prevention must be incorporated into project planning and design through formal dust-management plans approved by the relevant authorities.

These plans should be supported by online monitoring systems and independent third-party audits to ensure compliance.

Public transport and EVs

Nearly 65% of all journeys across MMR are already undertaken using public transport, making it the highest share among Indian regions.

Despite this, the number of registered vehicles has almost tripled since 2011.

MMR has two important opportunities: further increasing the share of public transport and transitioning the remaining vehicles towards electric mobility.

The region could take a leading role by prohibiting new registrations of petrol and diesel vehicles from 2031.

End waste burning

Although waste management has improved, the burning of municipal waste and plastic remains common in and around Deonar, Dharavi and other areas with high concentrations of informal settlements.

Such burning is particularly associated with waste recycling activities.

There must be zero tolerance for open waste burning.

Control fires

Forest and agricultural fires are becoming increasingly common across MMR.

Satellite-based fire detections increased from 5,716 in 2022 to 7,810 in 2025.

The government must introduce and effectively implement a comprehensive fire-control plan.

Clean cooking fuel

Approximately 45% of MMR’s population lives in slums and rural settlements, where solid fuels continue to be used alongside LPG.

Bakeries and eateries also rely on wood and coal for cooking.

Transitioning to LPG and electric cooking is both practical and achievable with appropriate government support schemes.

Green the region

Simply increasing road sweeping activities will not resolve the region’s dust pollution problem.

MMR needs a comprehensive greening programme that includes planting grass along suitable road edges, developing greenery on open land, expanding tree cover and increasing vegetation across the region.

Beijing’s “One Million Acres” afforestation initiative provides an example of how large-scale plantation programmes can help control dust pollution.

Monitor with purpose

Approximately 70% of MMR’s continuous air-quality monitoring stations are concentrated in Mumbai and Navi Mumbai, leaving large parts of the region without adequate monitoring coverage.

MMR needs a comprehensive monitoring network capable of identifying pollution hotspots, determining emission sources and guiding targeted interventions.

This should include:

  • Evenly distributed continuous air-quality monitoring stations.
  • A dense network of low-cost air-quality sensors.
  • Satellite-based pollution monitoring.

Combining information from these different monitoring systems will help authorities identify pollution sources and implement targeted measures in real time.

Implementing these measures can reduce Mumbai’s pollution by more than half within five years.

When You Catch a False Binary

In ‘Eyes Now on Viksit, Net Zero Later’ (Edit Page, Oct 16), Bjorn Lomborg argues that India’s ambition to become a developed country by 2047 and its commitment to net zero emissions by 2070 ‘work at cross-purposes’, and presents an ‘immense trade-off’ in which trying to achieve both will make Indians poorer. But data he quotes and reports he cites reach almost the opposite conclusion.

NITI Aayog’s study, ‘Scenarios Towards Viksit Bharat and Net Zero’, estimates that net zero needs $8.1 tn additional investment over the next 45 yrs. Lomborg divides this by today’s GDP and concludes that India must spend 4% of GDP every year for half a century to achieve net zero, more than it spends on education or health. This is fakery, not analysis.

The $8.1 tn is spent in an economy projected to grow to $30 tn by 2047, and keep growing thereafter. So, cumulatively, additional investment comes to 0.8% of GDP, 70% of which is required after 2050. Lomborg’s ‘4%’ would be correct only if India stopped growing after 2025.
Similarly, his comparison of net-zero investments with schools and hospitals equates apples with oranges. $8.1 tn is capex on solar, EVs and green steel, assets that earn revenue, most of them financed by banks, private capital and foreign investors, not by government budgets. A solar plant pays for itself, a primary school doesn’t – and shouldn’t. Claiming that a rupee of private capital is a rupee taken from a child’s classroom is intellectual dishonesty.
Worse, he has got his arithmetic wrong. Even if India’s spending on health and education stays at today’s share of GDP till 2070, the additional net-zero investment is at most ¼th of either. So, his claim of net zero seizing money from health and education is false.

He applies the same sleight of hand to every number he touches. Heat, he says, kills fewer than 90,000 Indians a year, while cold kills more than 6 lakh. So, concern about rising heat is misplaced. The figures come from a 2021 Lancet Planetary Health modelling study, whose conclusion he has reversed.

The authors’ summary reads: ‘Deaths related to hot temperatures increased in all regions from 2000 to 2019, indicating that global warming due to climate change will make this mortality figure worse in the future.’ This conclusion is substantiated by GoI’s data, which counted 19,693 reported heatstroke deaths and 15,197 cold-exposure deaths during 2001-19, with increasing mortality from heatstroke.

But mortality is only part of the cost. The Lancet Countdown estimates that India lost 247 bn potential labour hours to heat in 2024, 124% more than in the 1990s, resulting in income loss of $194 bn. Agriculture and construction accounted for 86% of the lost hours. These are costs of rising heat borne by the very workforce that will build Viksit Bharat. Yet, Lomborg trivialises the issue.

He similarly misrepresents ‘Climate Change Economics’ study to suggest that net zero could cost India over 20% of GDP a year. That figure comes from a scenario in which the world, India included, reaches net zero by 2050, 20 yrs before India’s target.

Finally, Lomborg dismisses India’s net-zero efforts because it would lower global temperature by only 0.16° C by 2100. This is the classic divide-and-rule tactic: measure each country’s contribution in isolation and conclude that nobody’s action matters. This is how he has justified inaction by the US, Europe and China in the past.

NITI’s report is a development-first analysis. Its conclusion is that India can become a developed economy in the net-zero scenario by decoupling growth from energy and emissions, cutting fossil-fuel imports, strengthening energy security, cleaning its air and building the industries of the future. Where the report does flag a problem – a $6.5 tn financing gap, much of it needing concessional finaance and grants from developed countries – Lomborg is silent.
If Lomborg wants to promote Viksit Bharat, he should go to Washington, Brussels and London and argue that the rich world, which built its prosperity on fossil fuels, should reach net zero faster and help finance the gap for those who did not. Otherwise, India does not need a lecture on trade-offs from a man who cannot read the report he cites.

Viksit Odisha through a Green Jobs and Skilling Mission in Odisha

Building a Skilled Workforce for a Viksit Odisha through a Green Jobs and Skilling Mission in Odisha

Odisha is at an important juncture in its economic transformation. The state has set an ambitious vision: becoming a $500-billion economy by 2036 and a $1.5-trillion economy by 2047, while creating more than one crore jobs. Achieving this will require more than attracting investment. Odisha must also ensure that its people have the skills to participate in, and benefit from, the new economy that this investment will create.

That change is already taking shape.

Renewable energy, green hydrogen, batteries, the circular economy and other green sectors are opening new avenues for employment and entrepreneurship. Odisha’s announced renewable energy targets, nearly 11 GW by 2030, alone could support around 30,000 jobs by 2030, with employment expected to nearly double by 2035. The state’s approved green investment pipeline could generate another 48,500 or more jobs over the next five to ten years. These are conservative estimates, largely capturing operations and maintenance jobs. The employment opportunity will be considerably larger once manufacturing, construction, logistics and services across these value chains are included.

The opportunity is not limited to energy. Nature-based solutions and the bioeconomy, including agroforestry, sustainable forest management and mangrove restoration, could generate around five lakh jobs over the next decade if developed at scale. Environmental services such as waste management, water management, air-pollution management and environmental monitoring will also grow with industrialisation, urbanisation and stronger environmental regulation.

But green growth will not simply create new occupations. It will also change existing ones.

Industries are adopting cleaner technologies, automation and more resource-efficient production processes. As a result, many existing jobs will require new competencies even when the underlying occupation remains the same. This makes workforce preparedness central to Odisha’s economic strategy. Skilling can no longer be viewed only as a social-sector intervention. It is an economic imperative.

The economic logic is straightforward. Skilling is an investment multiplier: capital translates into local wages, local enterprises and local tax revenue only when a trained workforce is available to absorb it. If the required skills are not available locally, employers may have to bring in workers from elsewhere, reducing the share of new economic value captured within the state.

Two workforce priorities

Odisha therefore needs to pursue two workforce strategies at the same time: upgrading the skills of its existing workforce and building new technical capabilities among those entering the labour market.

The first is largely a transition challenge, not a retraining challenge.

iFOREST’s assessment found that around 89% of the coal-mining roles assessed, including technical and operational roles, have high transferability to metal and critical-mineral mining. The gaps are primarily related to mine type, safety requirements and certification. Similarly, more than 75% of the technical and operational thermal-power roles assessed showed moderate-to-high transferability to renewable energy and green hydrogen.

The implication is important. Odisha does not need to replace its existing industrial workforce. It needs to identify transferable skills and provide targeted bridge training, certification and exposure to new technologies. The same principle can apply to emerging activities such as agroforestry, forest restoration and waste management, where training can be combined with market linkages and enterprise support.

The second priority is preparing young people for occupations that did not exist, or were much smaller, in the past. Here, the challenge is more fundamental. Only about 3.3% of Odisha’s working-age population has technical education and 3% has formal vocational training. Among youth, more than 95% do not have a technical qualification.

This gap cannot be addressed through short-term training alone. Technical and vocational capabilities must be built progressively through schools, higher and technical education, apprenticeships and workplace learning.

Build on Odisha’s Existing Skilling System through a Green Jobs and Skilling Mission

The good news is that Odisha does not need to build a new skilling system. It already has a substantial delivery network of ITIs, polytechnics, PMKVY centres, Jan Shikshan Sansthans, apprenticeship establishments and the World Skill Center. What is needed is to stregthen and better coordinate this existing system around the skills demanded by a growing green economy.

The two clusters Odisha has identified for industry-anchored ITI modernisation under PM-SETU provide an important platform for this shift. These hubs can anchor high-value green training, while the wider ITI and polytechnic network can function as spokes, taking training closer to workers and young people.

Infrastructure alone, however, will not be enough. Odisha needs a mechanism that brings together government departments, training institutions and industry to identify emerging skill demand, align training provision, mobilise finance and track employment outcomes. An Odisha Green Jobs and Skilling Mission, anchored within the existing Skill Development and Technical Education architecture, with an Apex body chaired by the Chief Secretary, can provide this coordination.

The Mission should work through the existing system rather than create a parallel one. At the state level, it can align departments and industry around sectoral workforce priorities; at the district level, it can identify local demand and connect employers with training institutions. It can also align existing state and central schemes, and development finance around clear sector- and district-level targets.

The focus must ultimately shift from inputs to outcomes. Enrolment and completion will remain important, but placement, wages, retention, career progression and entrepreneurship should increasingly define success.

Odisha has the institutions, infrastructure and growing investment pipeline to build a strong green workforce. What is needed now is a coordinated mission to ensure that the state’s green economic transformation creates opportunities for its people.

Time for a heat pump mission

India spends billions on oil and gas imports, facing economic and geopolitical risks. Heat pumps offer a cost-effective, energy-efficient solution to reduce import dependence and boost energy security.

Every year, India spends hundreds of billions of dollars to import crude oil and natural gas. In the last financial year, the net oil and gas import bill was $117.5 billion, roughly equal to the gross state domestic product of Punjab. Oil and gas imports, therefore, do not merely drain foreign exchange; they also expose the Indian economy to global price shocks and geopolitical risks, which we have experienced vividly in the last few months because of the US-Iran conflict.

There is now a broad consensus on the need to reduce this import dependence and make India more self-sufficient in energy. However, the policy conversation on reducing this dependence largely revolves around the visible frontiers of the energy transition — electric vehicles, green hydrogen, ethanol, and solar parks. But a large and largely ignored share of imported fuel is burnt for something far more mundane: heat. Diesel and furnace-oil boilers generating steam in factories, LPG and piped gas heating water in hotels and hospitals, and gas-fired ovens and dryers in automobile plants are all part of this hidden energy economy. In fact, about 40% of the energy used in Indian industry goes into generating heat — hot water, steam, and hot air.

For all this heat, a proven and commercially available technology can slash fuel use starting today. This technology is the heat pump — and it is perhaps the lowest-hanging fruit in India’s energy transition.

A heat pump does not generate heat; it moves it. It extracts warmth from the air, ground, or industrial waste heat and delivers it at useful temperatures. For every unit of electricity it consumes, it delivers two to four units of heat. No boiler or burner can match this efficiency arithmetic. And this is not a laboratory promise; these are commercially available technologies.

Largely Indian-made heat pumps are already running on factory floors across the country — at automotive facilities in Pune, pharmaceutical factories in Bengaluru, textile plants near Bhubaneswar, and electronics plants near Chennai — reliably delivering hot water and steam at temperatures up to 120°C under real operating conditions. Heat pumps that can deliver even higher temperatures are also available, but they remain expensive and are not yet widely deployed.

Studies conducted by my colleagues and me show that wherever heat pumps displace diesel, furnace oil, LPG, or piped natural gas, heating costs fall by 50 to 75%. A motorcycle plant that replaced its diesel boiler saw its cost of heat drop from `8.6 to `3 per unit. An electronics manufacturer replaced LPG-fired heating at `10 per unit with heat-pump heat at `3.5 per unit. In industries requiring low- to medium-temperature heat, heat pumps typically pay for themselves in under three years. In large hotels, hospitals, and hostels using electric heaters or LPG boilers, payback periods often fall below two years.

Our assessment shows that the easiest and most economic case for heat pumps today is precisely where they replace an oil or gas boiler or an electric resistance heater. Coal- and biomass-fired heat is harder to displace on cost today. But the imported-fuel segment — the one that matters most for India’s trade balance — is bankable right now

Consider what this means at a national scale. In industrial sectors dominated by MSMEs — dairy, textiles, pharmaceuticals, food processing, paper, and others — which require low- and medium-temperature process heat, heat pumps can easily meet one-fourth of the current energy demand at half the cost. This means higher profits for a highly stretched MSME sector and a lower import bill for the country.

In large hotels, hospitals, and hostels requiring hot water, heat pumps can eliminate almost all LPG, PNG, and diesel use. In colder regions, where the demand for hot water is high, the economics of replacing oil and gas boilers with heat pumps is even more attractive.

If we put all these demands together, India has a ready market to install 50 gigawatts (Gw) of heat-pump capacity over the next 15 years, significantly reducing the use of oil and gas in MSMEs and the commercial sector. It will also reduce carbon dioxide emissions by 54 million tonnes every year by 2040. This is why heat pumps sit at the strategic intersection of energy security and climate action.

So why is India’s installed heat-pump base still less than 1 Gw, with an annual market of only a few hundred crore rupees? The answer is not technology. Indian manufacturers already offer systems that can deliver heat up to 120°C. The barriers are upfront capital costs, low awareness, dependence on imported compressors, and the absence of any dedicated policy. India has national missions for solar, hydrogen, and electric mobility. It has none for the technology with arguably the fastest payback of them all.

But this policy gap can be fixed easily. Cutting GST on heat-pump water heaters from 18% to 5%, similar to solar water heaters, would reduce upfront costs. Interest subvention for commercial and MSME installations, similar to existing schemes run by the Bureau of Energy Efficiency to improve energy efficiency, would make heat pumps more attractive to small businesses. A production-linked incentive for high-temperature heat-pump manufacturing would help build a domestic compressor supply chain and make India self-sufficient in high-temperature heat-pump manufacturing. Similarly, minimum performance standards and star labels would allow buyers and lenders to trust the product.

None of this requires a technological breakthrough or a fiscal blowout. It requires recognising that the cheapest barrel of oil is the one we never import. India’s factories, hotels, and homes are already proving that heat pumps work here — in Indian conditions and at Indian tariffs. The gap between today’s less than 1 Gw and tomorrow’s 50 Gw is not a technology gap. It is a policy gap, and it is ours to close.

On World Ozone Day, Why We Aren’t Cheering Loudly

The Montreal Protocol has delivered, but it must transform to deal with new threats to the planet.

Four decades ago, the world did something remarkable. It discovered that refrigerants once celebrated as technological miracles were destroying the ozone layer, and it responded by negotiating a global treaty to phase them out. Crucially, the agreement recognised differentiated responsibilities: developed countries committed to funding the transition in developing countries.

The result has been extraordinary. The universally ratified Montreal Protocol has eliminated about 99% of controlled ozone-depleting substances (ODS). The ozone layer is healing and is expected to return to 1980 levels by around 2040 across most of the world.

Its climate benefits have been equally significant. Because many ODS are also potent greenhouse gases (GHGs), their phase-out has already spared the planet roughly 0.5°C of warming. The Kigali Amendment to the Montreal Protocol, adopted ten years ago to phase down another family of refrigerants, hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs), could avoid another 0.3–0.5°C of warming by 2100. In other words, without the Montreal Protocol, the world could be 0.8–1°C warmer by the end of this century.

On World Ozone Day, this success deserves celebration. But the best way to honour the Montreal Protocol is not to freeze it in time. It is to ask what the treaty must become over the next 40 years.

The fact is that the Protocol now faces challenges that could undermine its hard-won gains. New threats to the ozone layer are emerging. At the same time, the refrigerants and cooling technologies being promoted are creating new risks for the environment and the climate. The Montreal Protocol must therefore be transformed to deal with these emerging realities.

New threats to ozone

The refrigerants targeted by the Montreal Protocol are declining, but other major ODS remain uncontrolled. Nitrous oxide (N₂O), released mainly from nitrogen fertilisers and industrial processes, is now the single most important ODS emitted by human activities. Yet it is not controlled by the Protocol.

There is also the problem of ozone-depleting chemicals used as feedstocks for manufacturing other chemicals. These are exempt because they are assumed to be consumed during production. But a 2026 study found that actual ODS emissions from feedstocks are seven times higher than previously assumed. Continued emissions at these levels could delay ozone-layer recovery by close to a decade.

Then there is geoengineering. Proposals to inject sulphur particles into the stratosphere to reflect sunlight and cool the planet could alter stratospheric chemistry and damage ozone. The Montreal Protocol’s scientific bodies have already recognised this risk, but countries have not yet chosen to act.

To deal with these threats, the Protocol must become a treaty that governs any activity capable of damaging the ozone layer, whether or not the offending substance or activity is on its control list.

Threats to the environment

The Protocol has run on a chemical treadmill: replacing one refrigerant because of an environmental problem, only to discover another problem with its replacement.

First came chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs), which were phased out because they destroyed the ozone layer. They were replaced by hydrochlorofluorocarbons (HCFCs), which still damaged ozone, but less so.

HCFCs were therefore replaced by HFCs, which do not damage the ozone layer but are hundreds to thousands of times more potent than carbon dioxide in warming the planet. Now HFCs are being replaced by hydrofluoroolefins (HFOs), which damage neither ozone nor the climate.

But another problem is emerging. HFOs break down quickly into trifluoroacetic acid (TFA), one of the so-called “forever chemicals”, which no water treatment plant can remove. TFA is now in rainwater, rivers, groundwater and drinking water.

It is time to break this treadmill. The long-term direction should be towards technologies that avoid refrigerants wherever possible, and towards natural refrigerants, such as ammonia, carbon dioxide, propane and other hydrocarbons, that are safe across their full environmental life cycle.

Threats to the climate

The Montreal Protocol has focused on the gas that goes inside the cooling appliance. But the appliance itself matters just as much. Conventional air conditioners (ACs) and refrigerators are built on vapour-compression technology, which consumes large amounts of electricity. Over the lifetime of an AC, roughly 70% of its climate impact can come from the electricity it consumes, while only about 20–25% comes from the refrigerant.

With extreme heat contributing to half a million deaths every year globally, cooling is no longer a luxury but a matter of survival. That is why AC sales are soaring worldwide.

The International Energy Agency projects that the world’s stock of ACs will more than triple by 2050 and that cooling electricity demand will triple as well, putting electricity grids under severe strain. UNEP estimates that cooling-related GHG emissions could rise from 4.1 billion tonnes in 2022 to 7.2 billion tonnes by 2050. These numbers tell us that we cannot solve the climate challenge simply by putting a better gas into billions of highly energy-intensive machines.

We need low-energy solutions that already exist but are not being promoted. Buildings can be designed for passive cooling, and low-energy technologies such as evaporative and hybrid cooling can meet a significant share of demand. Similarly, centralised cooling can serve apartment and commercial complexes far more efficiently than millions of individual ACs.

This is where the Montreal Protocol must evolve: from a refrigerant-transition treaty into a sustainable-cooling treaty.

That does not mean abandoning its core mandate. It means extending the principles that made it successful: follow the science, help developing countries finance the transition, and strengthen the regime as knowledge evolves.

The Montreal Protocol saved the ozone layer because it was willing to change as the science changed. Its next test is whether it can change again. The bottom-line is that the ozone story should not end with a repaired sky, but polluted water and an overheated planet.

A Deficient Monsoon, a Devastating Flood

Global warming is changing the character of Assam’s floods. The state must prepare for it.

Assam received less rain than normal this July, yet parts of the state suffered their worst flooding in six decades. This paradox should worry us.

By the last week of July, Assam had received nearly a third less rainfall than normal, placing the monsoon in the “deficient” category. Yet Sivasagar, Charaideo, Jorhat and Golaghat -districts where most families had never experienced severe flooding in living memory -went under water.

The water also came with frightening speed. In parts of Sivasagar, families had at most an hour to pick up what they could carry before the flood entered their homes.

The flood was not caused by extraordinary rainfall over Sivasagar or Jorhat but was triggered by extreme rainfall in neighbouring Nagaland. On 19 July, parts of Nagaland received exceptionally heavy rain; in Mokokchung, rainfall was close to 500% above normal. Water rushed down the hills, entered the southern tributaries of the Brahmaputra and reached the plains of Assam within hours.

The new normal

It is tempting to describe this as a once-in-sixty-years event and move on. The evidence suggests otherwise.

Between 1980 and 2000, an average of 32,000 km² of Assam was at risk of flooding. Our assessment, based on multiple models, suggests that by mid-century, the area at risk could expand to 50,000–60,000 km². That is well over half of Assam.

Floods will also become deeper, and this matters more than it may appear. Assam has always lived with shallow flooding, and communities know how to cope with it. Deep flooding is different. It does not merely disrupt life; it destroys homes, crops, infrastructure and livelihoods.

Our analysis shows that the share of Assam exposed to deep flooding could rise from about 36% historically to between 50% and 60% in the coming decades. That is precisely what Upper Assam experienced in July: not the familiar, gradual rise of water, but a sudden and violent surge driven by extreme rainfall upstream.

Our assessment also reveals something even more uncomfortable. Over the next two decades, it makes surprisingly little difference to Assam’s flood risk whether the world cuts emissions quickly or slowly. Flood projections until around 2050 remain broadly similar across different IPCC emissions scenarios. The global warming that has already occurred is shaping Assam’s flood risk over the next quarter-century.

This does not mean that cutting greenhouse-gas emissions is unimportant. On the contrary, emissions reductions today will determine how severe climate impacts become after mid-century. But Assam’s immediate challenge is to live with increasing floods while drastically reducing the loss of lives, livelihoods and infrastructure.

Investing in resilience

This may sound daunting, but there are practical ways to adapt and build resilience. Consider what Assam has already lost. Between 2015 and 2024, floods and landslides caused officially recorded damage worth ₹27,925 crore. This figure mainly captures what can be counted – roads, bridges, embankments and other infrastructure. It does not fully capture the private economic and social costs, which are likely to be considerably higher.

Now consider the opportunity. Our modelling shows that if Assam plans according to climate risk, builds infrastructure to withstand floods and reduces the exposure of its poorest households, expected future losses could be reduced by nearly 70%, even as flood risk increases. Every rupee spent on flood resilience could save an estimated four to ten rupees in avoided damage.

The next ten to fifteen years therefore offer Assam a critical window to invest in resilience. Five things need to happen – and Assam already knows how to do all of them.

First, decide where people can build. Maps identifying areas exposed to deep flooding and erosion must be officially notified and made binding on town planning authorities, panchayats, public works departments and municipal bodies. New construction must be restricted in the highest-risk zones. Many such maps already exist. What is missing is a rule requiring everyone to follow them.

Second, change how Assam builds homes. The state needs a clear building code designed for a wetter, more flood-prone and hotter climate: raised plinths, heat-resistant roofs and materials that can withstand prolonged exposure to water. Compliance must be enforced through a robust building-permission system.

Assam does not need to look far for ideas on constructing flood-resilient houses. The traditional saang ghar is a powerful example of living with floods. Modern materials and engineering can adapt these traditional principles to create homes that are resilient to changing climatic conditions.

Third, build resilient infrastructure. Roads, power lines, airports, schools, hospitals and other critical infrastructure must be designed for future climate conditions rather than historical averages. Nearly half of Assam’s major road network passes through highly flood-prone areas. Every new road, substation or health centre should have to answer one simple question before it is sanctioned: what happens to this when the water rises?

Fourth, warn people earlier and provide relief faster. Warnings must reach people in local languages through radio, television, mobile phones and automated calls. Every panchayat and urban ward should have trained volunteer groups capable of supporting evacuation, rescue and relief. Systems must also ensure that compensation reaches affected families quickly so that they can rebuild their lives without falling into debt.

Fifth, and most importantly, work with neighbouring states. Assam cannot manage its floods alone because much of the water that floods the state originates outside its borders. The state needs a permanent working arrangement with neighbouring states. Rainfall and river-level data should be shared in real time, supported by a basin-wide warning system and coordinated management of upstream catchments.

This must also include an honest conversation about forest loss, hill cutting, roads and construction upstream. A rain gauge in the Nagaland hills that gives Sivasagar three additional hours of warning could save more lives than several kilometres of embankment. Such cooperation requires an institution with adequate funds, technical capacity and authority.

Beyond these five measures lies perhaps the cheapest flood protection Assam already possesses. Its wetlands, beels and catchment forests absorb, store and slow down water naturally. Restoring them can cost a fraction of providing equivalent protection through concrete infrastructure, while delivering ecological benefits that engineered structures cannot.

July has shown Assam that the character of flooding is changing. Places that believed they were safe are no longer safe, and floods that once developed slowly can now arrive within hours. In a warming climate, Assam can face devastating floods even in a deficient monsoon year.

The question is whether the floods of Sivasagar, Golaghat, Jorhat and Charaideo will be remembered merely as another tragedy – or recognised as a clear and present danger.

When The Rich World Sweats

If even FIFA World Cup was forced to pause for heat, the myth that developed nations can manage climate change is over. They should recommit to deep emission cuts, transfer finances & tech to developing world.

William Nordhaus was the poster child of the “global warming isn’t so bad” camp in the 1990s — precisely when the world was negotiating the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) and the Kyoto Protocol. His much-cited 1991 paper, ‘To Slow or Not to Slow’, projected that a 3°C rise in global temperature would shave barely 0.25% off US income. His later work went further, predicting gains for cold developed regions — lower heating bills, longer growing seasons, better farming in the US, Canada, Russia and Europe — while poor tropical countries bore the losses.

His DICE model, the first to link economy and climate, produced cost-benefit arithmetic under which letting substantial warming happen looked economically rational, because cutting emissions cost more than the discounted future damages. He was awarded the 2018 Nobel Prize in Economics for climate-economy work.

But Nordhaus was not alone. Thomas Gale Moore, a senior fellow at the Hoover Institution and a member of Ronald Reagan’s Council of Economic Advisers, argued that a warmer climate would bring net gains to cold northern countries. Nigel Lawson, a former Chancellor of the Exchequer of the UK, wrote An Appeal to Reason: A Cool Look at Global Warming, contending that warming’s costs were modest relative to expected economic growth and that carbon-reduction policies were politically unrealistic and economically damaging. Bjorn Lomborg, author of The Skeptical Environmentalist, still insists that global warming should not be a priority, because money spent cutting emissions hurts the poor.

While such voices are few compared with the pro-climate constituencies of the developed world, they have been disproportionately influential. They persuaded a critical mass of political and business leaders that global warming was essentially a problem of hot and humid developing countries; that colder developed countries might even benefit from modest warming; and that, in any case, the rich world had the money and tech to adapt to whatever came.

This school of thought has led to a slow breakdown of the international climate compact. Developed countries have reneged on their promises on emission cuts, finance and technology, while developing countries have struggled to move to a low-carbon trajectory.

Today, under the celebrated Paris Agreement, everything is voluntary and every country is on its own. Relations between developed and developing countries have soured to the point that, when last year’s climate conference in Belém could not agree on a roadmap away from fossil fuels, willing countries chose to pursue it outside the UN convention altogether.

But how wrong the likes of Nordhaus have proved to be. Global average temperature has risen by only about 1.5°C, and that has been enough to transform summers in the Northern Hemisphere. Temperatures once considered exceptional — near 40°C — are becoming the norm. Prolonged droughts, destructive wildfires and shrinking rivers are no longer freak events but recurring features of the European summer. Last year — the most destructive fire season in its recorded history — the European Union lost over one million hectares to wildfires, an area the size of Tripura and nearly double the historical average. And 2026 is tracking worse: over 450,000 hectares had already burned by end-July, well ahead of last year’s pace, including the largest fire Spain has ever recorded.

North America tells the same story. Canada has lost some 3.7 mn hectares this year — nearly the size of Kerala — and the United States about 2.4 mn hectares, larger than Mizoram, with the season’s peak still ahead.

The northern summer has changed so much that the two football World Cups hosted by the US, 32 years apart, were played under effectively different rules. In 1994, teams played two 45-minute halves. At the 2026 World Cup, every match carried two mandatory three-minute cooling breaks, one in each half — converting the game into four quarters — for fear of heat exhaustion. Project that trend 30 years forward: will outdoor sport in summer be possible at all in the US?

Yet the perception that “we can manage” — or even profit — still shapes the rich world’s diplomacy. The negotiations among Arctic Circle countries — scrambling to carve up the melting region’s oil, natural gas and rare minerals — are a clear example of this mindset.

But the economics that justified this complacency is now collapsing. Recent research by economists Adrien Bilal and Diego Kanzig finds that every additional 1°C of warming lowers world GDP by over 20% in the long run — damages many times larger than earlier estimates and borne by rich temperate countries as much as poor tropical ones. Against this, the cost of decarbonising the global economy is a small fraction of GDP. The bill the developed world will pay for solving the crisis is far smaller than the bill it will pay for an unchecked one — a truth its burning forests and drying rivers are already delivering.

So, it is still not too late. What is required is for developed countries to shed the short-sightedness that has shaped three decades of climate diplomacy and accept that greater capability means greater responsibility. That means deep emission cuts and serious adaptation investment at home — and finance and technology for developing countries, so that they too can pole-vault to greener technologies instead of repeating the fossil-fuelled path. Lives, economies and ecosystems everywhere are now in the line of fire; no one is safe from this planetary crisis.

The developed world would do well to remember an old village truth: when the whole village is on fire, wisdom lies in everyone coming together to save the village, rather than each person trying to save only their own house.

मोदी ने पर्यावरण संरक्षण को भारतीय मूल्यों से जोड़ा

नरेंद्र मोदी अब लगातार सबसे लंबे समय तक पद पर बने रहने वाले भारत के निर्वाचित प्रधानमंत्री बन गए हैं। इस मौके पर एक स्वाभाविक सवाल उठता है — आखिर पीएम मोदी का पर्यावरण-दर्शन क्या है? यह सवाल तब और महत्वपूर्ण हो जाता है जब हम उन्हें स्वच्छता, जल संरक्षण, जलवायु परिवर्तन और पर्यावरण संरक्षण जैसे विषयों पर लगातार बोलते सुनते हैं। शायद वे पहले ऐसे प्रधानमंत्री हैं जिन्होंने लाल किले की प्राचीर से बार-बार पर्यावरण को बेहतर बनाने की जरूरत पर जोर दिया है।

स्वच्छ भारत मिशन की शुरुआत

2014 में अपने पहले कार्यकाल में, पहले स्वतंत्रता दिवस भाषण में ही मोदी ने स्वच्छता और खुले में शौच को खत्म करने पर बल दिया था। स्वच्छ भारत मिशन को उन्होंने सिर्फ एक योजना नहीं, बल्कि एक राष्ट्रीय आंदोलन का रूप दिया। शुरुआती सालों में साफ-सफाई, पानी की किल्लत और मिट्टी की गुणवत्ता जैसे स्थानीय मुद्दों पर फोकस रहा।

2015 में घरेलू वायु प्रदूषण और साफ रसोई ईंधन का मुद्दा उठा, जो 2016 में प्रधानमंत्री उज्ज्वला योजना के रूप में सामने आया। इसके साथ ही ‘पानी बचाओ, ऊर्जा बचाओ, खाद बचाओ’ का नारा देते हुए प्रधानमंत्री कृषि सिंचाई योजना भी शुरू की गई। बाद के वर्षों में एकल-उपयोग प्लास्टिक के खिलाफ अभियान चलाया गया, जिसे कानूनी रूप भी दिया गया।

पिछले कुछ वर्षों में मोदी जलवायु परिवर्तन, नवीकरणीय ऊर्जा और टिकाऊ उपभोग जैसे वैश्विक मुद्दों पर अधिक सक्रिय नजर आए हैं। 2020 के बाद से उनके भाषणों में ऊर्जा और जलवायु परिवर्तन की चर्चा प्रमुखता से होने लगी। हालांकि इसकी जड़ें पुरानी हैं — 2009 में गुजरात के मुख्यमंत्री रहते हुए उन्होंने देश का पहला जलवायु परिवर्तन विभाग बनाया था और सौर ऊर्जा के शुरुआती समर्थकों में से रहे।

चार सूत्रों पर टिका पर्यावरण नजरिया

मोदी की पर्यावरण संबंधी सोच के पीछे चार प्रमुख सूत्र दिखते हैं:

पहला — जन-भागीदारी: सरकारी योजना से ज्यादा यह जनता की भागीदारी से बदलाव लाने पर जोर देता है। रसोई गैस सब्सिडी छोड़ने का गिव-इट-अप अभियान इसी का उदाहरण है। स्वच्छ भारत की कामयाबी का श्रेय भी टीम इंडिया और जन-भागीदारी को दिया जाता है।

दूसरा — सह-लाभ की अवधारणा: ऐसे काम जो अर्थव्यवस्था, पर्यावरण, जन-स्वास्थ्य को एक साथ फायदा पहुंचाएं। स्वच्छता, जल संरक्षण, रसोई गैस और बिजली पहुंचाने वाली योजनाओं से पर्यावरणीय सुधार के साथ लोगों का जीवन स्तर और स्वास्थ्य भी बेहतर हुआ है। हरित ऊर्जा की महत्वाकांक्षा के पीछे भी यही भरोसा है कि यह भविष्य के विकास और नौकरियों का जरिया बनेगी।

तीसरा — महिला-केंद्रित दृष्टिकोण: जल जीवन मिशन, उज्ज्वला योजना और स्वच्छ भारत अभियान जैसी पहलों में महिलाओं की सेहत, सुरक्षा, गरिमा और सुविधा को खास तौर पर ध्यान में रखा गया है।

चौथा — परंपरा और आधुनिक विज्ञान का मेल: पंच तत्व और हरित हाइड्रोजन की बात एक साथ करना इसी सोच की मिसाल है। संयुक्त राष्ट्र संघ की जलवायु वार्ताओं में भी उनकी पहल — पर्यावरण के लिए जीवनशैली, और भारत की संयमित उपभोग की परंपरा से जुड़ी रही है।

पंडित उपाध्याय के विचारों से जुड़ाव

इन चार सूत्रों को समझने के लिए पंडित दीनदयाल उपाध्याय के एकात्म मानववाद को समझना जरूरी है। इस विचारधारा में विकास का केंद्र मनुष्य होता है, और प्रकृति के साथ संतुलन बनाए रखने पर जोर रहता है। बेलगाम उपभोगवाद को इस सोच में भारतीय सभ्यता से बाहर का माना गया है। 1965 में बंबई में दिए गए अपने व्याख्यानों में पंडित उपाध्याय ने प्रकृति की रक्षा, टिकाऊ खेती और भारत के पारंपरिक ज्ञान को निखारते हुए आधुनिक विज्ञान अपनाने की बात कही थी।

विचार से जन-आंदोलन तक

मोदी के पर्यावरणवाद को एकात्म मानववाद का व्यावहारिक रूप कहना गलत नहीं होगा। उन्होंने पंडित उपाध्याय के विचारों को नया आयाम देकर इन्हें नीति, कार्यक्रमों और जन-आंदोलन में बदल दिया है। इस तरह उन्होंने भारत के पारंपरिक पर्यावरण एजेंडे को एक ऐसी पहचान दी है जो परंपरा और आधुनिकता के संगम पर खड़ी है — जन-भागीदारी, महिलाओं की गरिमा, जन-स्वास्थ्य, ऊर्जा सुरक्षा और आधुनिक तकनीक, सभी इसमें शामिल हैं।

Decoding Modi’s environmentalism

From Swachh Bharat to LiFE, the PM has given environmental agenda a distinctly Indian vocabulary rooted in Deendayal Upadhyaya’s integral humanism.

As Narendra Modi becomes India’s longest continuously serving elected Prime Minister, it is worth asking: What is his environmental philosophy, and what drives his environmentalism?

This question has often engaged me when I have heard him speak on cleanliness, water conservation, green energy, climate change, and ecological protection. He is perhaps the only PM who has spoken so consistently from the Red Fort about changing behaviour, practices, and policies to improve India’s environment.

In his first Independence Day speech in 2014, he spoke about cleanliness and the need to eliminate open defecation. He returned to the theme year after year, launched the Swachh Bharat Mission (SBM), and converted a subject of revulsion into a national movement.

In the early years, his focus was on local and traditional environmental problems — sanitation, indoor air pollution, water stress, waste, and soil health. More recently, he has engaged increasingly with globally relevant issues such as climate change, renewable energy (RE), and sustainable consumption.

Consider the local agenda first. In 2015, he highlighted indoor air pollution and the need for clean cooking fuel, which became the Pradhan Mantri Ujjwala Yojana (PMUY) in 2016. He also launched the Pradhan Mantri Krishi Sinchai Yojana with the slogan “save water, save energy, save fertilisers”. He has urged farmers to reduce fertiliser and pesticide use to protect soil, health, and nature, calling in 2021 for agriculture to be taken “out of the lab of chemistry” and connected to the lab of nature. On waste, after the SBM, he launched a campaign against single-use plastic, which was later backed by a ban on several such items.

Transitioning Local Activism

Energy and climate change have featured more prominently in his speeches since 2020, though the origins go back earlier. In 2009, as Gujarat’s chief minister, he set up India’s first climate change department. A votary of solar power since his Gujarat days, he expanded India’s solar and RE targets substantially and, in 2021, spoke of energy independence based on clean energy by 2047, including electric mobility, hydrogen, and a clean energy transition road map So, what philosophy explains these environmental actions? Four threads stand out.

The first is people-led change. People-centricity and mass mobilisation are central themes in his environmental policies and programmes. The pattern is clear: first build public consciousness, then follow it with policy.

The “Give It Up” campaign preceded the PMUY. His natural farming push is farmer-led. The Jal Jeevan Mission is framed as a Jan Andolan. The campaign against plastic began as a people’s movement before it became a legal ban. Swachh Bharat’s success has been credited by him to “Team India” and mass participation. Thus, PM Modi’s idea of the environment is linked to change at the level of individuals, households, and communities.

Socioeconomic Co-Benefits

The second thread is co-benefits. Actions that simultaneously improve the economy, environment, and public health seem to be a core motivation in his environmentalism. Flagship schemes delivering water, sanitation, cooking fuel, and electricity carry large environmental and health gains. For instance, one of India’s biggest air pollution gains in the last decade has come not from reducing vehicular emissions, but from the shift from biomass to LPG for cooking. His green energy ambition is also driven by energy security and the belief that future growth and jobs will come from the green economy.

The third thread is women-centricity. Improving the lives, health, and dignity of women runs through most of his programmes. He has described Jal Jeevan as a women-driven movement, framed the PMUY around women’s health and dignity, and said that women’s safety and dignity were central inspirations for the SBM. In this sense, his environmentalism is also the politics of everyday relief — less drudgery, cleaner homes, safer sanitation, and better health.

The fourth thread is a fusion of tradition and modern science. He invokes the panch tatva and green hydrogen in the same breath. His signature intervention at the UN climate negotiations — Lifestyle for Environment, or LiFE — draws from India’s tradition of restrained consumption.

But this belief in traditional wisdom has not stopped him from embracing modern science and technology. From building a digital economy to investing in electric vehicles and RE, his government has pursued technological modernisation with equal zeal.

Ultimately, to understand PM Modi’s environmentalism, one must understand Pandit Deendayal Upadhyaya’s integral humanism. In integral humanism, human beings are at the centre of development; culture moulds nature without destroying it; and unbridled consumerism is seen as alien to Indian civilisation. In lectures delivered in Bombay in 1965, Upadhyaya spoke about nature protection, sustainable agriculture, and the need to embrace modern science while improving upon India’s traditional knowledge and culture. In one of his lectures, he warned that chemical fertilisers could render land infertile. “How long can this dance of destruction go on?” he had asked. Modi’s passion for natural farming derives directly from that worldview.

PM Modi’s environmentalism, therefore, is best understood as integral humanism in practice. He has updated and expanded the ideas propounded by Upadhyaya. But his major achievement is that he has converted these ideas into policy, programmes, and mass mobilisation. In doing so, he has given India’s environmental agenda a distinctly Indian vocabulary — rooted in people, tradition, women’s dignity, public health, energy security, and modern technology.

 

Social media & sharing icons powered by UltimatelySocial